Crafting Memories, One Cookie at a Time

Explore Fountain City Sweets’ Custom Cookie Experience!

01

Black calligraphic letter 'a' with a loop and an arrow pointing upward and to the right.

Choose Flavor

02

Select the Level of Intricacy

03

Black and white line drawing of an infinity symbol turning into a check mark.

Enjoy Your Cookies!

Request Your Custom Cookies Now!
Decorative cookies celebrating graduation with messages such as "ESU Grad," "Class of '21," and "Stingers Up for Emily." The cookies feature graduation caps, diplomas, a cat wearing a graduation cap, and banners spelling "Emily."
Decorative cookies with various messages and designs, including references to Bob Ross, a newspaper cartoon, a coffee mug stating "World's Best Precept," and birthday greetings.
Assorted wedding cookies with pastel-colored icing, text, and decorative elements like a diamond ring, hearts, and words like 'love,' 'engaged,' and names 'Jack + Mariah'.
Cookies decorated for Halloween featuring haunted houses, pumpkins, ghosts, and signs with phrases like 'Open haunted house' and 'Sold by Keri'.
Decorated sugar cookies with themes of love and energy. Some cookies spell out words like "LOVE" and "Chicks," others have the phrase "BIG GAME ENERGY." There are cookies with hearts and the outline of the state of Ohio, decorated with pink, yellow, and white icing.

How Does it Work?

Elevate your special occasions with custom cookies tailored to your taste by ordering from us! Whether it’s a birthday party, a sophisticated wedding, or a corporate gathering, our streamlined process makes it easy to turn your cookie ideas into reality.

Start by picking your favorite flavor from our delectable options. Next, select the level of design details you prefer. Provide inspiration boards and specific event details in the order request form, and Sara will craft a unique set of edible art just for you!

Let us turn your events into delicious memories – submit your custom cookie request today!

Request Your Custom Cookies Now!

Step 1. Choose Your Flavor

Black and white icon of a person sitting at a desk with a computer, facing right

Signature Almond

Sara’s version of the classic sugar cookie, with just the right amount of almond flavor, just like her aunt used to make when she was little. It’s the cookie that put Fountain City Sweets in business!

Silhouette of a person taking a photo of the sunset over mountains with a camera

Lemon Poppyseed

As loved on the Food Network! Ree Drummond said this cookie was just like a lemon poppyseed muffin turned cookie! Paired with almond icing and this cookie hits just right!

Top view of a sliced lemon

Lemon Lavender

Subtle notes of lavender paired perfectly with a tangy lemon reduction. Complemented by a smooth vanilla royal icing.

A black silhouette of a person sitting in a meditative pose with crossed legs and hands resting on knees against a white background.

New Flavors Seasonally

Fountain City Sweets loves developing new cookie flavors and rotates seasonal flavors several times throughout the year.

Black and white outline of a dog walking on a leash.

Lavender Haze

This cookie brings together many of the flavors of a london fog latte and puts them in cookie form. The lavender and Earl Grey tea complement each other perfectly, with just the right amount of sweetness.

Silhouette of a person walking. Black background.

Celebration

Soft, chewy, and packed with sprinkles and white chocolate bits. Accompanied with a smooth vanilla royal icing.

Black clothing tag with the word 'CAUTION' in yellow and red text, with a yellow warning symbol below.

Vanilla Sugar Cookie

A comforting traditional cookie, packed with comforting buttery vanilla flavor. Paired with vanilla royal icing.

Request Your Custom Cookies Now!

Step 2. Choose Your Design

Cookies shaped like the number one with light blue icing, yellow moon decoration, and the word 'cadelor' written in icing.

Simply Sweet

1 dozen (flat rate) $114
2+ dozen (per dozen) $94

up to 2 designs
up to 3 colors, plus white
Simple designs with minimal text or detail

Collection of decorative cookies in various shapes and colors, including hearts, flowers, bottles, and plates, with pastel and gold embellishments, some with text such as "Bride To Be" and initials "M + A".

Sensational Set

1 dozen (flat rate) $154
2+ dozen (per dozen) $134

Up to 10 designs
Up to 10 colors, plus white
A mix of designs ranging from mid-level to high end details
Includes hand painted details and metallics, intricate piping and florals

Assorted cookies decorated with strawberries, flowers, and text celebrating a birthday, including images of strawberries, a cupcake, a strawberry cart, and the number one.

Signature Set

1 dozen (flat rate) $134
2+ dozen (per dozen) $114

up to 6 designs
up to 6 colors, plus white
A mix of designs ranging from simple to intricate to create a cohesive, balanced set of cookies

Cookies with the logo of the Central Plains Mavericks, a sports team, printed on white icing.

1 dozen (flat rate) $72
6+ dozen (per dozen) $70
12+ dozen (per dozen) $68

Great for showcasing business logos and branding!

Printed edible images on freshly baked and iced cookies. Please attach an image in PNG or JPEG format. White or light colored backgrounds work best with this printing process. Please note, edible image printing is of less quality than digital or printed images.

*Disclaimer: You must have the legal right to use the photography that you submit. We reserve the right to refuse to print a photograph that depicts hate, violence, or discrimination of any kind.

Printed Cookies

Pink background with peach and high heel cookie-shaped decorations, two cans of Barbie Peaches & Cream Lipgloss, and a sign that says "Simply Peachy."

Digital Content, Promotional, & Collaboration Cookies

Sara is grateful for the opportunity to team up on out-of-the-ordinary cookie projects. This includes working with clients, brands, large organizations, and small businesses. For more information and pricing on digital content creation, sponsorships, collaborations, or styled shoots, please contact Sara directly.

Step 3. Order Now

Book up to 3 months in advance with at least 2 weeks notice preferred.

For booking weddings more than 3 months in advance, please contact fountaincitysweets@gmail.com for possible availability.

If interested in a digital content and collaboration projects, please email Sara at fountaincitysweets@gmail.com

Thank you for your interest in custom cookies and patience during my break from the cookie studio while I recover from cancer related surgeries!

I am well on the road back to normal and so pleased to share I am taking orders for January - March!

Thank you again for your understanding and patience during this time!

What Client Says